What are Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution?

Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution methods play an important role in solving disputes outside regular courts. A tribunal is a specialised body established to deal with certain types of disputes, including labour issues, tax matters, or administrative conflicts. It is less formal than a formal court.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) includes methods like mediation, conciliation, and arbitration. It aims to resolve disputes faster, without going to court. Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution work together to provide a fair resolution of disputes in India.

Legal Skills Online Certificate Courses​ by PW-Enroll Now!

Role of Tribunals in Dispute Resolution

Tribunals focus on only certain types of disputes, aiming to provide faster justice than regular courts. Tribunals also act as first-line dispute resolvers, reducing the burden on regular courts. They encourage parties involved to settle disputes through ADR methods like mediation before moving to a full hearing. Some key points about their role are:

• Specialisation: Tribunals deal with areas including taxation, labour, environment, or consumer disputes. This specialisation helps in a better understanding of complex matters.

• Simple Procedure: Unlike courts, tribunals follow simple rules and regulations and do not require strict adherence to procedural laws.

• Speedy Resolution: Cases are decided faster because tribunals have fewer formalities and processes to undergo.

• Cost-effective: Tribunal proceedings are generally less expensive than court cases.

• Expert Members: Tribunals often have technical experts alongside judicial members to provide fair decisions.

Legal Skills Online Certificate Courses​ by PW

Judicial Mediation in Tribunals

Judicial mediation is the process through which a tribunal judge or member helps parties settle disputes without a full hearing. It is voluntary, i.e, both sides must agree to try mediation. For example, in a consumer tribunal, if a customer and a company dispute over defective goods, judicial mediation can help them agree on compensation without a full hearing. The working of a judicial mediation is explained below:

• Initiation: The tribunal may suggest mediation if it believes the dispute can be settled quickly.

• Role of Mediator: The judicial member listens to both sides and helps them find common ground.

• Confidentiality: Discussions are private and cannot be used later in court if mediation fails.

• Settlement Agreement: If parties agree, the tribunal records the settlement as a binding order.

Tribunal Annexed Mediation

Tribunal annexed mediation is a specific form of mediation connected to a tribunal. It is a bit different from judicial mediation because it is conducted by a trained mediator in place of a tribunal member. 

It helps in the reduction of backlogs in tribunals and encourages voluntary resolution without adversarial litigation. Some of the key features of the tribunal annexed under the Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution mechanism are summarised below:

• Independent Mediator: A neutral professional helps parties negotiate.

• Early Stage Intervention: Often used before the case reaches a full tribunal hearing.

• Binding Agreement: If parties reach a settlement, the tribunal approves it, making it legally enforceable.

• Flexibility: Parties can discuss creative solutions that a judge may not impose.

Tribunal vs ADR Mechanisms

Tribunals and other ADR mechanisms like arbitration, negotiation, and conciliation both focus on resolving disputes efficiently. For example, in a tax tribunal, a DRA with tax expertise may help a taxpayer and the tax department agree on disputed claims without a full hearing. The differences between the Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism are summarised in the table below:

Dispute Resolution Appointments (DRA)

Dispute Resolution Appointments (DRA) are such roles where trained professionals are appointed to help parties settle disputes under tribunal supervision. Some of the key points related to Dispute Resolution Appointments under the Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution mechanisms are:

• Appointment: The tribunal appoints a DRA when mediation or negotiation is suitable.

• Role: They guide parties through the settlement process and propose solutions.

• Expertise: DRAs may have legal, technical, or industry-specific knowledge.

• Outcome: Settlement proposals are submitted to the tribunal for approval.

Employment Tribunal ADR Options

Employment tribunals are established to take care of conflicts between employers and employees. Here, ADR methods can help resolve disputes efficiently while maintaining workplace relationships. Some of the common ADR options in employment tribunals are as follows:

• Mediation: A neutral mediator facilitates discussion and helps parties agree on compensation, workplace adjustments, or reinstatement.

• Conciliation: The mediator suggests solutions, but parties are not bound to accept. It is useful for cases like wrongful termination or salary disputes.

• Early Neutral Evaluation (ENE): A neutral expert evaluates the dispute and provides an assessment of the likely tribunal outcome. It encourages parties to settle early.

• Settlement Conferences: Informal meetings guided by tribunal-appointed officials. It focuses on quick, mutually acceptable resolutions.

Benefits of ADR in Employment Tribunals

• Reduces stress for employees.

• Helps in maintaining professional relationships.

• Speeds up resolution in comparison to formal hearings.

• Reduces costs for both employers and employees.

Tribunals Alternative Dispute Resolution methods are significant for India’s legal system. They provide quick, fair, and cost-effective ways to solve disputes. Tribunals bring specialisation, legal authority, and a structured approach. ADR methods like mediation, conciliation, and DRA offer flexibility and preserve relationships.