

Ruskin Bond’s A Question of Trust tells the story of Horace Danby, a skilled lock-maker whose passion for rare books leads him to commit theft. Although he appears to be a respectable citizen, he secretly plans a robbery every year to fund his collection. His carefully planned theft at Shotover Grange takes an unexpected turn when he meets a young woman who appears to be the owner of the house.
Alongside the chapter explanation, PW offers Class 10 batches and preparation resources to help you revise English lessons, practise important questions, and prepare for your board examinations. These resources can support your preparation across subjects through video lessons, revision, and question practice.
Horace Danby was a fifty-year-old, unmarried locksmith who lived with his housekeeper. Though considered respectable, he had a criminal past and had served one prison sentence fifteen years earlier. He loved collecting rare and expensive books, so he planned one robbery every year to fund his passion. He suffered from hay fever, which made him sneeze around flowers.
Horace selected Shotover Grange for his next robbery and studied the house for two weeks. On 1 July, he found the house empty as the family had gone to London and the servants were at the cinema. He entered using the kitchen-door key and planned to steal jewellery worth £15,000 from the safe.
He managed to calm the dog, Sherry, and located the safe behind a painting. After cutting the burglar alarm wire, he began opening the safe. However, the flowers in the room triggered his hay fever, making him sneeze repeatedly.
While Horace was sneezing, a young woman in a red dress appeared at the doorway. She claimed to be the owner's wife and threatened to call the police. Afraid of returning to prison, Horace requested that she let him go.
The woman then asked him to open the safe, claiming she had forgotten its combination and wanted her jewellery for a party. Trusting her story, Horace removed his gloves and opened the safe. He handed her the jewellery and left happily, believing he had escaped punishment.
However, the woman had actually been another thief who had tricked him. Two days later, Horace began planning his next robbery, unaware that his fingerprints would eventually lead to his arrest.
|
Horace’s Interpretation |
The Actual Situation |
|
The young woman was the owner’s wife. |
She was another thief. |
|
She had returned to collect her jewels. |
She had come to obtain the jewellery through Horace’s help. |
|
She was helping him escape punishment. |
She was manipulating him for her own benefit. |
|
Horace was robbing the house for himself. |
He was unknowingly committing the robbery for another thief. |
For chapter explanations, quick revisions, and important exam topics, subscribe to the PW Class 10 YouTube Channel
Horace did not get time to plan another robbery. The police arrested him that same afternoon for stealing the jewellery from Shotover Grange.
The police had strong evidence against him: his fingerprints. Horace had removed his gloves while opening the safe, leaving his fingerprints throughout the room.
He tried to explain that the owner’s wife had asked him to open the safe, but nobody believed him. The real owner’s wife then appeared. She was about sixty years old, grey-haired, and sharp in her manner. She dismissed Horace’s account as nonsense.
The truth was now clear. The young woman was not the owner’s wife. She was a thief who had used Horace to carry out the robbery. Horace had unknowingly worked for another criminal.
He was sent to prison again. In an ironic turn of events, he worked there as an assistant librarian, surrounded by the books for which he had committed his yearly robberies.
Want regular classes, revision sessions, tests, and doubt support for your board preparation? Check the PW Class 10 Batches.
Horace often thought about the charming and clever woman who had deceived him. She was also a thief, but she had successfully gained his trust and used it against him.
The experience changed his understanding of the saying “There is honour among thieves.” This expression suggests that thieves remain honest and loyal to one another. Horace became angry whenever he heard it because his experience proved the opposite.
The title, A Question of Trust, focuses on the central issue: whom should a person trust, and how much trust should be given? Horace trusted the woman without checking her identity or confirming her story. She exploited his blind trust and caused his return to prison.
The story gives two important lessons:
Do not trust someone blindly. It is important to know the truth and verify information before relying on another person.
Wrongdoing has consequences. A person may escape punishment for some time, but dishonest actions can eventually lead to serious consequences.
The story highlights several themes that help explain its message and the choices made by its characters.
The central theme is trust. Horace believes the young woman is the owner’s wife and accepts her story without checking it. She takes advantage of his belief and gets him to open the safe.
Horace considers his yearly robberies a way to fund his love for books. However, his personal reason does not make the crime acceptable. His arrest shows that dishonest actions can have serious consequences.
The young woman appears confident and behaves as if she belongs to the house. Horace judges her by her appearance and manner instead of verifying who she is. Her real identity is revealed only after his arrest.
The ending is ironic because Horace, who committed robberies to buy rare books, ends up working as an assistant librarian in prison. The books he wanted so badly are now around him, but he cannot enjoy them as he had planned.
Preparing for the English board exam? Practise applying these themes to chapter-based questions with PW’s CBSE Class 10 Sample Papers.
Want to understand how Horace’s carefully planned robbery goes wrong? Watch this PW video session for a complete explanation of A Question of Trust, including the characters, the unexpected twist, and the moral of the story.
A Question of Trust shows how Horace Danby’s confidence in his own plans leads him to overlook the truth about the young woman. His experience highlights the importance of thinking carefully before trusting someone and reminds readers that dishonest actions can have lasting consequences.
To revise this chapter and prepare for other Class 10 subjects, use PW’s video explanations, study resources, and school preparation batches. Regular revision and question practice can help you understand the chapters better and prepare more confidently for your board exams