Doctrine of Ultra Vires, Meaning, Purpose, Exceptions, Effects

Enroll Now For Commerce Batch 2025

What is the Purpose of Doctrine of Ultra Vires?

The Doctrine of Ultra Vires is designed to protect both creditors and investors in a company. It restricts the company from using investor funds for purposes not specified in the memorandum's object clause. This means investors can be confident that their money will only be used for the intended activities. By doing so, the doctrine safeguards against unauthorized spending that could harm the company's financial health. Misusing a company's assets can lead to insolvency, leaving creditors unpaid. Additionally, this doctrine prevents directors from straying from the company's original purpose, ensuring they operate within defined boundaries. It acts as a check on their actions, helping them understand the scope of their authority and responsibilities in managing the company.

Scope of the Doctrine of Ultra Vires

The Doctrine of Ultra Vires is applicable only to companies that are legally incorporated and recognized as separate entities under the law. This means that unregistered businesses, such as sole proprietorships and partnerships, do not fall under the doctrine's jurisdiction. Only those companies that have been officially formed and hold a distinct legal identity are subject to the Doctrine of Ultra Vires. However, not every illegal transaction or abuse of authority by a company's directors or employees falls within the doctrine's scope. The doctrine specifically addresses transactions that exceed the powers granted to the company as outlined in its Memorandum of Association. The purpose and permissible activities of the company are detailed in the object clause of this document. Therefore, if a company acts beyond the limits defined in its object clause, such actions can be scrutinized under the Doctrine of Ultra Vires.

What are the Exceptions to the Doctrine of Ultra Vires?

While the doctrine of ultra vires is a fundamental principle in corporate law, there are several notable exceptions where actions beyond the company's scope of authority may still be considered valid. These exceptions include:

• The directors can authorise an act within the company's object clause but beyond their authority.
• Shareholders can approve an ultra vires act performed irregularly within the company.
• If a company acquires property through an ultra vires investment, the company's right to that property can still be defended.
• Any incidental or significant effects of an act are not considered ultra vires unless expressly prohibited by statute.

What are the Effects of Doctrine of Ultra Vires?

Members of a company can issue an injunction to prevent the company from engaging in any ultra virus activities.

• Ultra Vires Contract : An ultra vires contract is void ab initio, meaning it cannot be given legal status even through ratification or estoppel. The issue here concerns the company's competence and authority to enter into the contract, not its legality.
• Liability of the Company: There are no established principles regarding a company’s liability for damages resulting from an ultra vires act. However, tortious liability may arise if it can be convincingly shown that the activity during which the ultra vires act or tort occurred falls within the scope of the Memorandum of Association and happened during employment.
• Breach of Warranty: Acts that a company is prohibited from performing, as stated in the Memorandum of Association, are also beyond the authority of its directors, who act as agents of the company. Therefore, contracts considered ultra vires to the company will be void. Directors must act within the scope of the company’s powers; otherwise, they could be held personally liable for breach of warranty.
• Protection of Shareholders and Creditors : The doctrine safeguards the interests of shareholders and creditors by ensuring that the company's funds and resources are used only for legitimate and authorised purposes.
• Restriction on Corporate Powers : This restriction limits the company's powers to only those activities explicitly stated in its constitution or charter, preventing unauthorized expansions of business activities.
• Legal Consequences for Directors : Directors and officers may be held personally liable for any ultra vires actions, as they ensure the company operates within its legal boundaries.
• Preservation of Corporate Integrity : The doctrine helps maintain the company's integrity and compliance with legal and statutory requirements, fostering trust and stability in corporate operations.

Begin your journey towards academic excellence in Commerce with our comprehensive Commerce courses . Master the CBSE syllabus with expert guidance and ace your exams. Enroll now!”