
Collision problems involving friction are an important part of JEE Advanced Mechanics. Questions often involve blocks moving on rough surfaces, objects sticking together and bodies colliding with walls, where assuming friction acts throughout the collision or confusing maximum frictional impulse with actual frictional impulse can lead to incorrect answers.
For focused revision, Physics Wallah’s Collision notes for JEE Physics help you revisit essential concepts, impulse-momentum principles and frictional impulse calculations. Review the formulas below and practise applying them to collision problems to improve accuracy in JEE Advanced.
A 5 kg block moves horizontally at 2 m/s on a rough horizontal surface. A 1 kg object is dropped vertically onto it with a downward speed of 10 m/s. The object sticks to the block. The coefficient of friction between the block and the ground is 0.4.
Since the collision is momentary, the objects move together immediately after impact with a common horizontal velocity V.
The collision involves both horizontal and vertical momentum changes. The vertical impulse helps determine the normal impulse, which is then used to calculate the possible frictional impulse.
Consider the block and the dropped object as a single system.
The contact force between the two objects is internal to the system. The weight of the objects is a non-impulsive force during the very short collision and can be neglected.
Initially, the dropped object has downward vertical momentum:
Initial vertical momentum = 1 × 10 = 10 kg m/s
After the collision, the combined system has zero vertical velocity.
Therefore, the change in vertical momentum is 10 kg m/s upward.
The ground provides an upward normal impulse:
Normal impulse = 10 N s
This normal impulse is used to determine the maximum possible frictional impulse during the collision.
A frequently used calculation is:
Frictional impulse = Coefficient of friction × Normal impulse
Frictional impulse = 0.4 × 10 = 4 N s
The initial horizontal momentum of the block is:
Initial horizontal momentum = 5 × 2 = 10 kg m/s
The total mass after the collision is:
Total mass = 5 + 1 = 6 kg
Applying the horizontal impulse-momentum equation:
-4 = 6V - 10
Therefore:
V = 1 m/s
The numerical answer is correct in this case. However, directly using the maximum frictional impulse without identifying the type and duration of friction does not provide complete physical reasoning.
A correct numerical result does not necessarily validate the method used to obtain it.
The ground is stationary, whereas the block initially moves horizontally at 2 m/s.
Therefore, relative motion exists between the block and the ground. Kinetic friction acts initially.
The two main types of friction are:
Kinetic Friction: It acts when two contacting surfaces slide relative to each other.
Static Friction: It acts when there is no relative slipping between the contacting surfaces and prevents relative motion from starting.
Static friction cannot act initially in this example because the block is already sliding relative to the ground.
The correct initial relation is:
Kinetic friction = Coefficient of kinetic friction × Normal reaction
The normal reaction may act throughout the collision interval, represented by Δt. However, kinetic friction acts only while relative slipping continues.
Let Δt₁ represent the duration for which kinetic friction acts.
The kinetic-friction impulse is:
Kinetic-friction impulse = μₖ × Normal impulse accumulated during Δt₁
Therefore:
Δt₁ ≤ Δt
If slipping continues throughout the collision, Δt₁ = Δt.
For the given coefficient of friction, the maximum possible frictional impulse is:
Maximum frictional impulse = 0.4 × 10
Maximum frictional impulse = 4 N s
Using this impulse:
-4 = 6V - 10
V = 1 m/s
Since the final horizontal velocity is positive, the combined system continues moving in the original direction.
Therefore, slipping continues throughout the collision, and the assumption of full-duration kinetic friction is self-consistent.
The final velocity must always be checked after calculating the frictional impulse.
A positive final velocity indicates that the system continues moving in the original direction.
A zero final velocity indicates that the relative slipping has stopped.
A negative final velocity obtained by assuming full-duration kinetic friction may indicate that the assumed frictional duration is incorrect.
The actual motion must determine the frictional impulse, not simply the maximum value allowed by the coefficient of friction.
Now consider a larger coefficient of kinetic friction of 2.2.
The maximum possible frictional impulse is:
Maximum frictional impulse = μₖ × Normal impulse
= 2.2 × 10
Maximum frictional impulse = 22 N s
If kinetic friction is assumed to act throughout the entire collision, the horizontal impulse-momentum equation becomes:
-22 = 6V - 10
Therefore:
V = -2 m/s
This negative velocity is not the physically valid result under the assumed friction model.
The initial horizontal momentum is 10 kg m/s in the forward direction.
A backward frictional impulse of only 10 N s is sufficient to reduce the horizontal velocity to zero.
Once the block stops sliding relative to the ground, kinetic friction cannot continue acting in the same direction to reverse its motion.
Therefore:
Slipping stops before the collision ends.
Kinetic friction acts for a shorter duration.
The actual frictional impulse is 10 N s.
The final horizontal velocity is zero.
The impulse required to stop the slipping is:
Required frictional impulse = Initial horizontal momentum
Required frictional impulse = 10 N s
The normal impulse accumulated during the slipping period can be calculated using:
Actual frictional impulse = μₖ × Normal impulse during slipping
10 = 2.2 × Normal impulse during slipping
Therefore:
Normal impulse during slipping = 10/2.2 N s
The kinetic-friction impulse is limited to the amount required to stop the slipping.
After slipping stops, static friction can maintain zero relative velocity if required. In this example, no further horizontal frictional impulse is necessary.
Memory Tip: Friction does not automatically apply its maximum possible impulse. It acts according to the relative motion between the surfaces. A negative final velocity can indicate that the assumption of full-duration kinetic friction is invalid.
Consider a cube sliding without friction on a horizontal floor and colliding with a vertical wall. One face of the cube is parallel to the wall.
The coefficient of friction between the cube and the wall is 2, and the coefficient of restitution is one-half.
The initial velocity makes an angle of 37° with the wall.
Let the initial speed be v.
Resolving the velocity into components:
Component parallel to the wall:
vₜ = v cos 37°
vₜ = 4v/5
Component perpendicular to the wall:
vₙ = v sin 37°
vₙ = 3v/5
The collision changes the normal and tangential components differently.
For a collision with a fixed wall, the coefficient of restitution determines the normal component of velocity after impact.
Coefficient of restitution = Final normal speed / Initial normal speed
Therefore:
Final normal speed = Coefficient of restitution × Initial normal speed
vₙ' = 1/2 × 3v/5
vₙ' = 3v/10
The normal velocity reverses its direction after the collision.
If the mass of the cube is m, the normal impulse is calculated using the change in normal momentum.
Normal impulse = m(3v/5 + 3v/10)
Therefore:
Normal impulse = 9mv/10
Struggling with frictional impulse and advanced collision problems in JEE preparation? Strengthen your concepts with PW’s JEE batches
The maximum frictional impulse available at the wall is:
Maximum frictional impulse = Coefficient of friction × Normal impulse
= 2 × 9mv/10
Maximum frictional impulse = 9mv/5
The initial tangential momentum is:
Tangential momentum = m × 4v/5
Tangential momentum = 4mv/5
To eliminate the tangential velocity completely, friction must provide a tangential impulse equal to the initial tangential momentum.
Required frictional impulse = 4mv/5
The maximum available frictional impulse is:
Maximum frictional impulse = 9mv/5
Since:
9mv/5 > 4mv/5
The available frictional impulse is sufficient to eliminate the entire tangential component of velocity.
Therefore, the cube loses its tangential velocity and rebounds only in the normal direction.
The final velocity is perpendicular to the wall.
Angle of rebound with the wall = 90°
The important point is that the actual frictional impulse required to stop tangential slipping is 4mv/5, not the maximum available impulse of 9mv/5.
Follow these steps to solve advanced collision problems involving friction:
Identify the system and calculate the initial momentum.
Calculate the normal impulse using the impulse-momentum principle.
Identify whether relative slipping exists at the beginning of the collision.
Apply kinetic friction when relative slipping is present.
Calculate the maximum available frictional impulse.
Compare it with the impulse required to eliminate the relative tangential velocity.
If slipping continues, calculate the frictional impulse over the slipping duration.
If slipping stops early, limit the kinetic-friction impulse to the amount required to stop slipping.
Check whether static friction is needed to maintain zero relative velocity.
Verify that the calculated final motion is physically consistent.
These steps help avoid incorrect assumptions about frictional impulse and make collision problems easier to approach systematically.
Collision concepts are essential for solving advanced mechanics problems involving impulse, momentum and friction in JEE Physics. Revise kinetic and static friction, normal impulse, frictional impulse and slipping conditions carefully, and practise applying them to block and wall collision problems. PW’s Collision notes for JEE Advanced help you strengthen these fundamentals before moving to more complex mechanics topics.
|
Resource Name |
Link |
|
JEE Syllabus |
|
|
JEE Advanced Formulas |
|
|
JEE Advanced Sample Paper |
|
|
JEE Advanced PYQs |