
Profitability analysis is an important part of Plant Design and Economics in Chemical Engineering. It helps evaluate whether a plant project is financially practical by examining investment costs, operating savings, selling prices, depreciation, taxes and the time value of money. Concepts such as break-even analysis, payback period, discounted cash flow and net present value are commonly used to assess project viability.
For candidates preparing for GATE 2027 Chemical Engineering, understanding these concepts involves learning the underlying formulas and applying them to numerical problems. GATE Wallah offers Chemical Engineering courses, with concept-focused learning, topic-wise and subject-wise tests, multiple-subject tests, full-length tests and performance tracking to support preparation.
A plant requires an investment of ₹30 lakh and saves 40 gigajoules of energy per year. At an interest rate of 10%, the break-even cost of saved energy can be determined by equating the initial investment with the present value of future savings.
Let x be the cost of energy saved per gigajoule.
30,00,000 = 40x/1.10 + 40x/(1.10)² + 40x/(1.10)³
The present value of the three annual savings is used because the savings occur in future years and must be discounted at the given interest rate.
At break-even:
Total Cost = Total Revenue or Total Savings
Using the equation above:
30,00,000 = 40x × [1/1.10 + 1/(1.10)² + 1/(1.10)³]
This gives an approximate value of:
x ≈ ₹30,160 per gigajoule
The reported answer in the source is approximately ₹3,00,102 per gigajoule. However, this does not match the supplied equation and values. The calculation should be checked against the original question before publishing the final numerical answer.
Also, check:
A reduction in selling price lowers the cash earned from each unit sold. If the cost price and initial investment remain unchanged, the cash available to recover the investment generally decreases, increasing the payback period.
|
Quantity |
Original Case |
New Case |
|
Selling Price |
S |
0.8S |
|
Cost Price |
Unchanged |
Unchanged |
|
Payback Period |
PP₁ |
PP₂ |
|
Given Relation |
— |
PP₂ = 1.5 PP₁ |
The selling price decreases by 20%, making the new selling price 80% of the original value.
The given relationship is: PP₂ = 1.5 × PP₁
This means the new project takes 1.5 times the original payback period to recover its investment.
The transcript also reports a final ratio of 0.5, but the exact quantity represented by this ratio is unclear. Therefore, the reliable conclusion is that a reduction in selling price can increase the payback period when other important costs and investment conditions remain unchanged.
Net Present Value (NPV) is used to compare the present value of expected cash inflows with the initial investment. The calculation considers the time value of money and the cash flows generated during the evaluation period.
In the given example, the income-tax rate is 20%, and the evaluation period is two years. Depreciation is calculated using the double-declining-balance method.
Annual depreciation is not constant under this method. It is calculated using the book value at the beginning of each year.
Using a depreciation rate of 20%:
Initial book value = Rs. 20 crore
Year 1 depreciation = 20 × 0.20 = Rs. 4 crore
Book value after Year 1 = 20 − 4 = Rs. 16 crore
Year 2 depreciation = 16 × 0.20 = Rs. 3.2 crore
|
Year |
Depreciation |
|
Year 1 |
Rs. 4 crore |
|
Year 2 |
Rs. 3.2 crore |
The after-tax cash flow is calculated using:
After-Tax Cash Flow = (Profit − Expenses − Depreciation) × (1 − Tax Rate) + Depreciation
The annual cash flows provided are:
ACF₁ = Rs. 4.8 crore
ACF₂ = Rs. 4.64 crore
At a discount rate of 10%:
NPV = −I + ACF₁/(1 + i)¹ + ACF₂/(1 + i)²
Where:
I = Initial investment
ACF₁ and ACF₂ = After-tax cash flows for Years 1 and 2
i = Discount rate
The reported result is:
NPV ≈ −₹1.80 crore
A negative NPV indicates that the present value of expected cash inflows is lower than the initial investment under the given assumptions.
However, the supplied initial book value of ₹20 crore and the two stated cash flows do not produce an NPV of −₹1.80 crore when substituted directly into the formula. The original question's investment and cash-flow details should be verified before confirming the final answer.
The key concept is that depreciation changes every year under the double-declining-balance method. Therefore, after-tax cash flow must be calculated separately for each year.
Planning your GATE CSE and DA 2027 preparation in the final six months? Follow this last six-month roadmap for GATE CSE and DA 2027.
In a greenfield project, the plant begins operation two years after project initiation. When calculating the discounted cash flow for the fourth project year, the discounting period is determined using the project timeline.
The discounted cash flow in Year 4 is:
DCF₄ = ACF₄ / (1 + i)⁴
The fourth-year after-tax cash flow is:
ACF₄ = (Profit − Expenses − D₄) × (1 − Tax Rate) + D₄
Here, D₄ represents depreciation for the relevant year.
Two timelines must be distinguished:
Project-Initiation Timeline: Determines the period used for discounting cash flows.
Plant-Operating Timeline: Determines when operating income and depreciation begin.
The examination solution applies fourth-year discounting to the fourth project year. However, depreciation may follow a different timeline depending on the applicable depreciation rules and when the plant becomes operational.
Therefore, candidates should distinguish between:
Discounting period: Based on the project timeline.
Depreciation period: Based on the applicable depreciation rules and plant-operating status.
This distinction is important in numerical questions involving delayed construction, commissioning or plant start-up.
Break-even quantity is the number of products that must be sold to cover the fixed costs. At this production and sales level, the total contribution equals the fixed cost.
The formula is:
Break-Even Quantity = Fixed Cost / (Selling Price per Unit − Variable Cost per Unit)
The given data include:
Fixed cost = ₹60 lakh
Working capital = ₹30 lakh
Cost price = ₹600
Selling-price information is reported as approximately ₹40 lakh, although the spoken wording is unclear.
The denominator represents the contribution per unit:
Contribution per Unit = SP − VC
Where:
FC = Fixed Cost
SP = Selling Price per Unit
VC = Variable Cost per Unit
The reported break-even quantity is approximately:
30,000 products
The transcript also mentions a selling-price figure of approximately ₹30,000, but its units and exact meaning are unclear. The original question should be checked to confirm the selling price and variable cost per unit before verifying the reported break-even quantity.
Memory Tip: Remember the break-even quantity formula as:
BEQ = FC / (SP − VC)
The denominator is the contribution per unit.
A plant produces 20,000 tonnes per year. A modification increases the yield from 70% to 80%. The modification costs ₹10.9 crore, and the raw material costs ₹60,000 per tonne.
The payback period can be calculated by comparing the initial modification cost with the annual savings generated through reduced raw-material consumption.
At 70% yield:
20,000 / 0.70 = 28,571 tonnes/year
At 80% yield:
20,000 / 0.80 = 25,000 tonnes/year
28,571 − 25,000 = 3,571 tonnes/year
The annual monetary saving is:
3,571 × ₹60,000 ≈ Rs. 21.43 crore/year
The payback period is:
Payback Period = Initial Investment / Annual Saving
Substituting the given values:
Payback Period = ₹10.9 crore / Rs. 21.43 crore per year
Therefore:
Payback Period ≈ 0.5 years
|
Condition |
Yield |
Raw Material Required |
|
Before Modification |
70% |
28,571 tonnes/year |
|
After Modification |
80% |
25,000 tonnes/year |
|
Saving |
— |
3,571 tonnes/year |
The higher yield allows the plant to maintain the same production output while using less raw material. The resulting annual savings help recover the modification cost in approximately half a year, based on the supplied figures.
Profitability analysis connects engineering decisions with financial evaluation through concepts such as break-even cost, break-even quantity, payback period, depreciation, after-tax cash flow and NPV. For GATE 2027 Chemical Engineering, you should understand how to apply these formulas, discount future savings and distinguish between project timelines and plant-operating periods.
GATE Wallah offers GATE Online Chemical Engineering courses with concept-focused learning, tests, and performance tracking to support subject preparation. You should use these learning and practice resources to strengthen your understanding of Plant Design and Economics alongside your GATE preparation.